Explore Music Menu

The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever

Posted by: Alan Cross | Feb 19 2010 12:00AM

Plagiarism is an awful thing. It’s when you appropriate someone else’s work and then claim it for your own. It’s immoral, unethical and in many cases, illegal.

Now consider this: Mike Batt is a British guy best known for writing parody songs. As a joke, he issued a CD featuring a track called "One Minute of Silence." And it was exactly that: sixty seconds of nothing. However, this is where the problem began. John Cage was an avant-garde composer who issued a piece called "4'33"" in 1952.

It consisted of a pianist sitting down to and playing nothing for four minutes and thirty-three seconds of silence. When Mike Batt’s "One Minute of Silence" came out, John Cage’s people accused Mike of artistic theft and sued him for plagiarism.

The case went to court–and believe it or not, Mike Batt had to pay John Cage’s people an undisclosed amount of money. For recording...nothing.



Filed Under: Ongoing History of New Music


COMMENTS (5)

BeN
RE:The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever
Feb 19 2010 3:15PM
I'll try not to broadcast too much silence on my shows .. I might end up with a few thousands legal actions against me every week! So ridiculous .. but as Corey St-Pierre mentionned .. you made my day as well! LOL!

John Cage should get busy suing...
RE:The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever
Feb 19 2010 12:24PM
http://lpcoverlover.com/2008/03/02/the-sound-of-silence/

Alex
RE:The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever
Feb 19 2010 9:58AM
I prefer Simon and Garfunkel's version. Surprisingly, not all that silent.

Colin Principe
RE:The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever
Feb 19 2010 6:41AM
Another silly suit had to have been when John Fogerty was sued by Fantasy Records for plagiarising..... himself. Fantasy alleged that "The Old Man Down the Road" was a rip-off of Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Green River." Luckily sanity prevailed and Fogerty was victorious.

Corey St. Pierre
RE:The Silliest Plagiarism Suit Ever
Feb 19 2010 1:04AM
Ha! That's so silly. It made my day.

Leave a Comment

Name

 

Email

 

 

Comment On

 

Post Your Comment

 


Disclaimer: Comments submitted to this sites posts are moderated and will be posted to the website once they are deemed to be suitable.

Ongoing History of New Music Bio
   

Ongoing History of New Music LogoThe Ongoing History of New Music debuted in February 1993 on radio station 102.1 The Edge/Toronto. Since then it's...well, it's taken on a life of its own. Consider: More than 500 different one-hour episodes have been produced, making it the longest-running music documentary in Canada and one of the longest in North America. More than 5,000 one-minute daily features have been written and produced. The program is syndicated on virtually every major rock station in Canada. The Ongoing History of New Music show has spun off four books (all written by Alan Cross), which have worldwide sales of over 30,000 copies, not to mention almost 20 different compilation CDs (including four official Ongoing History discs).

 

twitter
Follow Alan Cross on Twitter

Show Schedule

The Ongoing History of New Music can be heard on the following stations:

OHNM Stations

On Air Schedule:

Week of July 18, 2010
Alternate Histories

Week of July 25, 2010
Before They Were Famous

Week of Aug 1, 2010
Kings of Leon: In Their Own Words 1

Week of Aug 8, 2010
Kings of Leon: In Their Own Words 1

Week of Aug 15, 2010
Dave Grohl 1

Week of Aug 22, 2010
Dave Grohl 2

Week of Aug 29, 2010
Fans and Fatalities

Edge.caY108CFOXPower 97FM96Rock 101.9